Contact Saint Matthew

Contact Us

4100 East 56th Street
Indianapolis, IN 46220-5599
Phone: 317-257-4297

Parish Office

No walk-ins permitted for everyone’s safety. If you wish to meet with a particular staff person, please make an appointment. We ask you to contact us via phone or email as much as possible. Thank you.

In an emergency, follow the after-hours instructions at the main Parish number: 317-257-4297.


If you wish to meet with a particular staff member, we ask you to please make an appointment. Thank you.

Bulletin Submissions

Our bulletin deadline is Monday at 8 a.m. We have early deadlines around holidays. We encourage you to submit information as far in advance as possible for planning purposes and because of limited space. Submit your information to our bulletin editor.

Staff Listing

Rev. J. Nicholas Dant
317-257-4297, extension 2100

Debbie Ward
Director of Music Ministry
317-257-4297, extension 2213

Marie Carson
Business Manager
317-257-4297, extension 2212

Loral Tansy
Pastoral Associate/Operations Manager
317-257-4297, extension 2211

Cari Weibel
Youth Minister
317-257-4297, extension 2210

Susan Pines
Communications Administrator/Administrative Assistant
317-257-4297, extension 2216

Jeni Lengerich Pleiss
Director of Faith Formation
317-257-4297, extension 2215

Saint Matthew Catholic Church and School

  • 4100 East 56th Street
    Indianapolis, IN
  • 317-257-4297


Join the Parish

Welcome! Click here to learn about joining Saint Matthew Parish. Or stop by our Welcome Table in the narthex for information about Saint Matthew Church and School.